John Penny “On Authenticity”

Previous Story

Jarrett Min Davis “On Authenticity”

Next Story

On Authenticity – Series of Short Essays

Wooden Cube and Measuring Stick by John Penny

I think that your fundamental question is interesting but extremely vague. I understand your question about authenticity to involve relevance. Because what lies at the heart of your questions is the possible meaning of what one understands by the word “authentic”. Authenticity was a buzz word for Martin Heidegger, and the Frankfurt School writers really took him to task over it. The whole question of authenticity in art and cultural production is now permanently coloured by that set of considerations and the ensuing debate.

Hence, I prefer to think of your question in non-absolute terms and use relevance as a yard-stick. If the work is relevant to its historical moment then it is authentic, either on a personal or public level. I would make a distinction between historical moment and fashionable interest, unless that fashionable interest was of a critical nature. The question of fashionable awareness and critical or historical awareness is not essential to art production, but does make a difference to the importance of the artwork to the viewer in terms of its relevance. In other words, the issue of the the work being simply a matter of entertainment, craft, or diversion rather than of critical intellectual engagement stems from its perceived relevance to the viewer and that viewer’s circumstances. Any perception of relevance that the work has is inherent in the context for the work that is provided by the viewer, that is, how the interpreter of the artwork (as a sign) constructs the relevance of the sign that is under consideration. This understanding follows on from C.S. Peirce’s definition of a sign being that which means something to someone. The issue of essentialism is another whole discussion that is very fraught.

– John Penny

Related Stories
Baltimore art news updates from independent & regional media

D. Watkins awarded James Beard Media Award, 10 DC exhibitions, Bailey Anne Kennedy first trans woman to win Miss Maryland, Easton Chef Harley Peet wins a James Beard award, Sheila E. and the Original Wailers headline Artscape, AFRO profiles Rachel D. Graham, and more.

A Design-Based Campaign Makes Brazil’s Current Environmental Crisis Visible and Poignant

Água até Aqui @aguaateaqui (High Water Mark) is an initiative that aims to be a visual alert for the extreme consequences of the climate crisis currently in south Brazil but applicable everywhere.

The best weekly art openings, events, and calls for entry happening in Baltimore and surrounding areas.

Pride Portraits at Current, Station North Art Walk, Bethesda Painting Awards, Clayworks Seconds Sale , Bria Sterling Wilson opening at Waller Gallery, Se Jong Cho and Iris Hughey + Alex Ebstein at Current, Art After Hours at the BMA, Pride Party at B&O, and MiCasa SuCasa celebration at Tola's Room

Spring Has Sprung, Thrice

This spring, check out Crossroads by the Enoch Pratt Library's artist-in-residence Hoesy Corona, the two-person show from Markus Baldegger and Heejo Kim False Relations at C. Grimaldis Gallery, and Goya Contemporary's Joyce J. Scott shows Bearing Witness and NOW