So often in dramedies, the pulse of the story becomes obscured by the writers in vainglorious attempts to sound ‘smart’ or ‘hip’. But the tender-hearted play, Primary Trust—Everyman Theatre’s newest entry on the Baltimore theater scene—reminded me of how refreshing it is to take a seat and just watch a good telling of a tale, with a couple of surprises, more than a few smiles, and an occasional heart-tug that arrives at an ultimately satisfying ending.
Just as Broadway has long been favoring small-scale intimacy like Passing Strange or Avenue Q as opposed to some of the big-box Broadway musicals, Primary Trust has snagged multiple awards, including a Pulitzer for Best Drama and the Lortel Award for Best New Play. And blessings to Everyman Theatre for continuing their tradition of bringing some of the best little known (at least to me) plays to their beautiful space on Fayette Street in downtown Baltimore. Sometimes, the simplest stories pack the biggest punch.
Kenneth is a warm-hearted, mild-mannered, unassuming 38-year-old guy living a quietly predictable life in Cranberry, New York, just 40 miles west of Rochester. Cranberry is a fictional small town, mostly white but with a sprinkling of people of color, where most of the inhabitants get along with each other and with Kenneth, with the exception of one incident that is never fully revealed. Kenneth has worked for 18 years for the local bookstore, Yellowed Pages. We are introduced to him at his favorite hangout, Wally’s Tiki Hut, where he spends his evenings after work slinging back Mai Tai’s and talking to his best friend and confidant, Bert. The fact that Bert is imaginary makes him the perfect sounding board and wing man.
The Tiki Hut is staffed by a series of servers (all played by the same actor), one of whom, Corina, catches the shy guy’s eye. When Kenneth finds out from his boss at the bookstore that he will have to soon find a new job, he is floored. The store is the only job he’s ever had and the owner and his wife are apparently the only family he knows. His mother died when he was very young and he grew up in a home for boys. This turn of events leads him into a new job at one of the town’s two banks, The Primary Trust. When a customer upsets him with her criticisms, it sets off a totally unexpected and dramatic response from Kenneth. The story effectively resolves itself with a suitable ending, not exactly happy but not exactly—not.