What To Do When You Get a Bad Review

Previous Story

Sondheim Finalists announced for 2013

Next Story

Lotta Fun = School 33’s 2013 Lotta Art! by [...]

Tough Love for Artists in Pursuit of Press by Cara Ober

What to do when you get a bad review?

In a word: nothing. Or, in a few words: add the byline to your CV and move on. Oh, and be really happy if they spell your name correctly and include an image.

Every artist wants a review of a new exhibit, show, or project. Every artist wants a good review. Press is an essential element of success. Proof that you’ve *really made it big* includes well-informed accolades from the New York Times, Art Forum, the New Yorker, and, of course, an Art 21 Video. But, for most of us that’s just not going to happen.

The good news is all press is good press, whether it’s a neighborhood newsletter, a friend’s blog, or the local newspaper or hipster zine. For an artist building a career, press is important. It generates interest, exposes the work to a new audience, proves relevance, and serves as a historical record, so that your labors are remembered.

There are many many more artists than capable arts writers, so the odds are not in the artists’s favor for press coverage. Not every project you do will be written about and chances are even less, as you climb the ladder of success, that your work will be reviewed favorably. Why? Because familiarity breeds deference and, as your work is viewed by a larger audience and a better-read, more experienced critic, your insider status (which does soften a reviewer’s opinion) is lost. As you grow as an artist and, ideally, your work is reviewed in a number of different publications, you will also grow a necessary attribute which is imperative to your success: a thick skin and a stubborn belief that your work is brilliant, no matter what the critics say.

Remember those mean critiques in art school that made you cry? Remember how unfair the critic was, how they didn’t take the time to really understand your concepts, how they dismissed your in-progress works? After these experiences, artists are left to lick their wounds and some quit, while others become stronger. Some might even find a gem of truth in the critic’s assessments and make their work better, too. Now, do you remember the positive critiques from school? Nope? This speaks volumes. After a particularly dismissive critique, the successful artist realizes this individual will never see things the way you do and will never like your work. At this point, the proactive thing to do is cut them loose and don’t ever make work to please them.

Art reviews, especially in larger, more powerful publications, are seldom accurate and will never fully capture the artist’s ideas, work, and process. Some are even downright misleading. (Try being dissed by the Washington Post Chief Art Critic for work you didn’t even make. Seriously.) This kind of press hurts, can feel humiliating, and can be harmful to an artist’s development. However, the critic is entitled to their opinions, mean-spirited ones and hurried ones and all. Hopefully all of this makes you more appreciative of a reviewer who actually ‘gets’ what you do and takes the time to do accurate research.

It should also make you realize that bad reviews are particularly unhelpful to young artists, new venues, and even emerging art scenes. Sometimes the press coverage we desire isn’t appropriate for our current career stage. When a publication ignores your work, don’t take this as a sign your work is bad, rather that it isn’t ready. And breathe a sigh of relief.

Bottom line, an art critic has to be critical – so this means you’re going to get reactions anywhere from good to bad. Of course, we hope for the good, for something not half-assed, but we should always expect a a review to make us feel slightly uncomfortable.
If your work was reviewed less-than-glowingly in NY Art blog Art F City’s “We Went to Baltimore: Jumbo Mumbo, Part Two” series, there is no need to feel bad. Just count yourself as lucky if your name and image has been exposed to a national audience and add a new line to your resume. Then get yourself back in the studio and don’t read it again.
Author Cara Ober is Founding Editor at BmoreArt. She is the recipient of lots of good reviews as well as a few whopping bad ones.
Related Stories
A graduation ceremony is a symbol, a photo opportunity, a rite of passage, but doesn't live up to the hype in real life

Instead of a traditional ceremony, the class of 2020 has a chance to invest creative energy in unique, authentic, and personal forms of celebration

Podcasts may have messed with filmmaking a little bit

With all of us ostensibly inside, talking less or at least talking to less people, the appeal of hearing voices that aren’t our own for extended periods of time has taken on a certain restorative luster.

10 Must-Read Stories from Baltimore-Based Writers and Publications

Coronavirus updates from Baltimore Brew, Maryland Matters, Baltimore, Real News Network, Fishbowl, Baltimore Magazine, and a selection of relevant articles published by Baltimore-based journalists for a variety of publications

A studio visit with Safiyah Cheatam, Afrofuturist, conceptual and social practice artist, UMBC Intermedia & Digital Arts MFA Candidate

Like Afrofuturists before her, Cheatam carries on the legacy through her evolving studio practice, through her daily existence, and through elements that incorporate her training as a filmmaker.